Why So Many ‘Serums’ Are Actually Oils
If you’ve ever picked up a bottle labeled “Vitamin C Serum” or “Retinol Oil Serum” only to find it feels like a silky oil on your skin, you’re not imagining things. The skincare industry has blurred the lines between face oils and serums so much that many so-called “serums” are, in reality, oils in disguise.
This isn’t just a semantic issue — understanding what’s really in that bottle determines how you use it, how effective it is, and how well it fits into the rest of your routine. In this guide, we’ll break down why brands use the term “serum” so loosely, how to tell the difference between an oil and a serum, and why it matters for your skin health and results.
What Serums and Oils Are — And Why They’re Not the Same
To understand how marketing has blurred the terminology, we need to start with the scientific definitions.
-
Serums are typically water-based treatments containing small-molecule actives like vitamin C, peptides, hyaluronic acid, or niacinamide. Their lightweight texture and molecular size allow them to penetrate deep into the skin, where they treat specific concerns like wrinkles, pigmentation, or dehydration [1].
-
Face oils are lipid-based blends made from botanical oils, seed extracts, and fatty acids. They don’t penetrate as deeply but instead nourish, strengthen, and protect the skin’s outer barrier while locking in moisture [2].
In short: serums are corrective and targeted; oils are supportive and protective. Both are valuable, but they do very different jobs.
See the Face Oil Collection →
See the Face Serums →
Why So Many “Serums” Are Actually Oils
So if the definitions are clear, why do so many oil-based products get marketed as serums? The answer is part psychology, part marketing strategy, and part formulation evolution.
1. “Serum” Sells Better Than “Oil”
The word serum signals potency, science, and results. It tells the consumer: “This product will do something.” In contrast, oil sounds nourishing but less transformative.
Brands know this. Labeling a product a “serum” — even if it’s oil-based — immediately elevates its perceived value, often allowing companies to charge more [3]. Consumers associate serums with advanced skincare and are more likely to use them consistently, so the label alone increases sales potential.
2. Oil-Serum Hybrids Are Becoming More Common
Some modern formulas genuinely straddle the line between serum and oil. They blend lipid carriers (like squalane, plum kernel, or jojoba oil) with potent actives (like bakuchiol, vitamin C esters, or retinol).
These hybrid products act like serums — targeting fine lines, hyperpigmentation, or texture — but have an oil base that nourishes and protects. In these cases, the “serum” label isn’t completely misleading, but the product still behaves more like an oil on the skin [4].
3. Consumers Don’t Know the Difference — And Brands Don’t Mind
Most skincare shoppers don’t understand the difference between water-soluble and oil-soluble formulas — and many brands count on that. If a product is lightweight, concentrated, and comes in a dropper bottle, most consumers assume it’s a serum.
This confusion works in the brand’s favor, allowing them to stretch the definition without pushback. As long as the product delivers some results, few customers question whether it’s technically a serum or an oil [5].
4. Marketing Leverages Ingredient Names
Brands also know that terms like “Vitamin C Serum” or “Peptide Serum” perform far better in search results and on social media than “Vitamin C Face Oil.” Even if the product contains those actives in an oil base, the serum label makes it more discoverable and more desirable.
How to Tell If Your “Serum” Is Actually an Oil
The good news is that it’s pretty easy to decode what’s inside the bottle once you know what to look for. Here’s how to spot an oil-based product disguised as a serum:
1. Check the Ingredient List (INCI)
The ingredient list tells the truth, even if the label doesn’t. Look at the first three to five ingredients:
-
If you see water (aqua), hydrosols, or floral waters listed first — it’s a traditional water-based serum.
-
If you see botanical oils (like jojoba, squalane, plum kernel, or marula) at the top — it’s an oil or oil-serum hybrid [6].
2. Look at the Texture
-
True serums: Lightweight, watery or gel-like, absorb quickly with no oily residue.
-
Oil-based serums: Silky, emollient, sometimes slightly greasy, leave a nourishing film on the skin.
Texture alone isn’t definitive, but it’s a strong indicator.
3. Pay Attention to the Delivery System
Traditional serums often come in pump bottles or airtight dispensers to protect delicate water-soluble actives. Oil-based “serums” are frequently packaged in dropper bottles or opaque glass vials — packaging more suited to lipid formulations.
4. Watch for Solubility Clues
If the product mixes easily with water-based serums or disappears instantly on damp skin, it’s likely water-based. If it repels water, sits on the surface, or needs to be massaged in, it’s probably oil-based [7].
Does It Matter If a Serum Is Actually an Oil?
You might be wondering — does it really matter what we call it, as long as it works? The answer is yes — because how a product functions in your routine depends on its base and molecular behavior.
1. Layering Order Changes
Water-based serums should always go before oils. Applying an oil first can create a barrier that prevents serums from penetrating effectively [8].
If you think you’re using a “serum” and layer it first — but it’s actually an oil — you could be blocking the rest of your routine.
2. Expectations Should Match the Formula
A true serum penetrates deeply and delivers actives to the lower layers of the skin. An oil primarily works at the surface, nourishing and protecting the barrier.
If you’re targeting pigmentation or collagen production, you need a water-based serum. If you want barrier support and glow, an oil is ideal. Misunderstanding which is which could lead to disappointing results.
3. Price and Performance Transparency
Many oil-based products are less expensive to produce than advanced water-based serums. When brands label them as “serums,” they can charge a premium — but consumers may not get the deep-acting benefits they expect [9]. Knowing what you’re paying for helps you make smarter decisions.
The Rise of Hybrid “Oil Serums”
While some brands blur the line purely for marketing, many modern formulations intentionally combine the best of both worlds. These oil serums use lipid carriers to stabilize active ingredients and improve their delivery.
Examples include:
-
Vitamin C oil serums: Use oil-soluble vitamin C derivatives that penetrate without irritation.
-
Bakuchiol oil serums: Offer retinol-like results without dryness or redness.
-
Peptide oil serums: Pair lipid nourishment with collagen-stimulating peptides.
These products are powerful — but they’re still oils first, serums second. They function best as the final step in a routine, sealing in hydration and protecting the skin barrier.
The Future: Transparency and Smarter Skincare
As skincare consumers become more ingredient-savvy, brands are beginning to face pressure to label their products more accurately. Expect to see more nuanced terminology like “oil serum,” “treatment oil,” or “concentrate” emerge in 2026 and beyond.
This shift is a good thing — it empowers you to choose products based on what they actually do rather than what the label claims. And once you understand the differences, you can build a smarter routine: water-based serums first, lipid-based products second, and results that go deeper and last longer.
Final Thoughts: Knowledge Is Your Best Skincare Tool
At the end of the day, “serum” and “oil” are just words — but the science behind them matters. A true serum is a deep-delivering, water-based treatment designed to correct and transform. A face oil is a nutrient-rich, barrier-supporting lipid layer designed to nourish and protect.
When a product labeled “serum” is really an oil, it’s not necessarily a bad thing — but you need to know what you’re using so you can apply it in the right order, pair it with the right products, and set the right expectations.
Understanding this difference turns you from a passive product user into an informed skincare strategist — and that’s how you get results that last.
See the Face Oil Collection →
See the Face Serums →
References
-
Draelos, Z.D. “Formulation and delivery of serum actives.” Skin Pharmacology and Physiology, 2023.
-
Elias, P.M. “Lipid barrier and topical delivery.” International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 2023.
-
Patel, R. “Consumer perception and terminology in skincare marketing.” Journal of Cosmetic Marketing Research, 2023.
-
Kim, S. et al. “Hybrid oil-serum formulations.” Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology, 2023.
-
Ganceviciene, R. et al. “Consumer behavior and skincare literacy.” Clinical Dermatology, 2022.
-
Rawlings, A.V. “Ingredient analysis and formulation function.” Dermatologic Therapy, 2023.
-
Tsai, T.F. “Solubility and absorption in topical products.” Cosmetic Dermatology, 2023.
-
Dreno, B. et al. “Layering strategies for effective skincare.” International Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2023.
-
Schagen, S.K. “Cost vs. composition in cosmetic formulations.” Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2023.
